8e4c70f02b
const validation: remove check for mutable refs in final value of const This check rejects code that is not necessarily UB, e.g. a mutable ref to a `static mut` that is very carefully used correctly. That led to us having to describe it in the Reference, which uncovered just how ad-hoc this check is (https://github.com/rust-lang/reference/issues/2074). Even without this check, we still reject things like ```rust const C: &mut i32 = &mut 0; ``` This is rejected by const checking -- the part of the frontend that looks at the source code and says whether it is allowed in const context. In the Reference, this restriction is explained [here](https://doc.rust-lang.org/nightly/reference/const_eval.html#r-const-eval.const-expr.borrows). So, the check during validation is just a safety net. And it is already a safety net with gaping holes since we only check `&mut T`, not `&UnsafeCell<T>`, due to the fact that we promote some immutable values that have `!Freeze` type so `&!Freeze` actually can occur in the final value of a const. So... it may be time for me to acknowledge that the "mutable ref in final value of const" check is a cure that's worth than the disease. Nobody asked for that check, I just added it because I was worried about soundness issues when we allow mutable references in constants. Originally it was much stricter, but I had to slowly relax it to its current form to prevent t from firing on code we intend to allow. In the end there are only 3 tests left that trigger this error, and they are all just constants containing references to mutable statics -- not the safest code in the world, but also not so bad that we have to spend a lot of time devising a core language limitation and associated Reference wording to prevent it from ever happening. So... `@rust-lang/wg-const-eval` `@rust-lang/lang` I propose that we allow code like this ```rust static mut S: i32 = 3; const C2: &'static mut i32 = unsafe { &mut * &raw mut S }; ``` `@theemathas` would be great if you could try to poke a hole into this. ;) |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| assembly-llvm | ||
| auxiliary | ||
| codegen-llvm | ||
| codegen-units | ||
| coverage | ||
| coverage-run-rustdoc | ||
| crashes | ||
| debuginfo | ||
| incremental | ||
| mir-opt | ||
| pretty | ||
| run-make | ||
| run-make-cargo | ||
| rustdoc | ||
| rustdoc-gui | ||
| rustdoc-js | ||
| rustdoc-js-std | ||
| rustdoc-json | ||
| rustdoc-ui | ||
| ui | ||
| ui-fulldeps | ||
| COMPILER_TESTS.md | ||